. Spanish Solar 1 & 2 Ltd v. Kingdom of Spain
-
Official Registry: ICSID Case Detail
-
Social Intelligence & Civil Society:
-
Civil Society (Facebook/Web): Plataforma por un Nuevo Modelo Energético (The main Spanish NGO fighting for renewable energy rights).
-
Investigation: Simmons & Simmons: Will more investors renounce claims? (Legal analysis of Spain’s settlement offers).
-
. The Spanish Solar Cases (The “Small Investor” Crisis)
-
The Problem: Spain owes billions to hedge funds but refuses to pay. Meanwhile, 60,000 Spanish families were ruined by the same policy changes but get nothing.
-
1. Commitment (Defendant/Spain):
-
“The Reinvestment Option”: Spain offers to pay the awards in tax credits rather than cash, provided the investors reinvest in new Spanish infrastructure.
-
-
2. Deterrence/Settlement Amount:
-
Outstanding Awards: €1.5 Billion+
-
The “Deal” Amount: 80 cents on the Euro.
-
-
3. The “Spillover” Project (Your Charity’s Proposal):
-
Project Name: “The Solar Victims’ Debt Jubilee”
-
Concept: A debt-forgiveness vehicle for the small Spanish families.
-
Mechanism: The Hedge Funds (Claimants) agree to contribute 2% of their settlement into this Fund. The Fund buys the bad debts of the small families from Spanish banks at a discount and forgives them.
-
Why it works: The Hedge Funds get a “ESG/Social Responsibility” gold star (very valuable for them). Spain gets to say “We fixed the problem for our citizens,” making the payout politically survivable.
-
2. Spanish Solar Cases (The “Renewables” Class)
The Dispute: Spain lured investors with subsidies, then cut them.
The “Shadow Class” (Tort Victims):
-
Class A: The “Small Solar” Families: 60,000 Spanish families took loans to build solar panels and were bankrupted when Spain cut the rates. They cannot afford arbitration (only big funds can).
-
Class B: The “Tariff Deficit” Consumers: Spanish electricity rate-payers who are overcharged to pay for the legal mess.
Your Targets & Contact Data:
| Group Name | Role / Interest | Contact / Email | Social Intelligence |
| ANPIER | The Small Investor Union. Represents the 60,000 families. | info@anpier.org |
X: @ANPIER_Asoc
Web: anpier.org |
| UNEF (Unión Española Fotovoltaica) | The Industry Lobby. Represents the solar companies generally. | info@unef.es |
X: @UNEF
LinkedIn: UNEF Solar |
| Plataforma Nuevo Modelo Energético | The Activists. Campaign for energy democratization. | contacto@nuevomodeloenergetico.org |
FB: Nuevo Modelo Energético |
Expert Opinion: ANPIER is your critical ally. They have the “moral high ground” (ruined families) that the Hedge Funds (Claimants) lack.
